The Rings of Power Season 3: Why Amazon's Billion-Dollar Show Still Can't Make an Impact
Here's the strangest thing about The Rings of Power Season 3.
By audience scores, it's the show's best-received season yet. And somehow, it still doesn't feel like anyone's talking about it.
Let me explain. Because this one genuinely confuses me.

The numbers that say "better"
Season 3 premiered on Prime Video on 11 November 2026, with four episodes, then two more on 18 November and the final two on 25 November.
The audience scores have gone up every season, even if the critics have cooled slightly:
Season 1 (2022): critics 84%, audience 38%
Season 2 (2024): critics 85%, audience 58%
Season 3 (2026): critics 79% (early), audience 74% (early)
That audience jump, from 38% to 74%, is big. But there's a catch: Season 3's audience score is built on only a few dozen ratings, compared with thousands for Season 1. And reviews only cover the first half of the season.
The money
This is the part everyone remembers. The Rings of Power is often called the most expensive TV show ever made, with Amazon's total commitment widely reported at around $1 billion, including a reported $250 million for the rights alone. Season 1 by itself was reported at roughly $465 million.
When you spend like that, "pretty good" isn't the goal. Cultural event is the goal.
Our take: why it still isn't landing
My opinion, clearly labelled.
1. It lost people in Season 1 and never got them back. Even Forbes noted the "precipitous drop" in viewership in Season 2. Higher scores now may simply mean that the people who disliked it have left. Happier viewers, fewer of them.
2. Beautiful isn't the same as gripping. One critic called Season 3 visually stunning but said it "never comes together as a compelling story". That's been the complaint since day one. The money is on screen. The heartbeat isn't always.
3. The culture war ate the conversation. Since 2022, every discussion about this show has turned into an argument about the casting instead of the story. That noise drowned out whatever the show was trying to say.
4. Weekly drops in a binge world. Splitting eight episodes into three batches keeps it on the calendar, but it also makes it easy to forget. Without social media hype, a slow rollout just feels... slow.
5. Middle-earth has impossible shadows. Peter Jackson's films are sacred to a generation. Anything set in that world gets compared to them, and almost nothing wins that fight.
Is it a failure? Not exactly. It's a gorgeous, improving show that arrived too late to win back the crowd. That might be worse.
Vishal Waghela is the Co-Founder of AltBollywood, where he leads content and creative strategy. He writes about Indian pop culture, the internet and the place where AI meets culture, usually with more feelings than footnotes. Follow him on Instagram at @vishal.waghe1a.





Comments