Prince William Took the Mumbai Metro. Will He Apologise to India?
The Earthshot Prize celebrates India’s search for cleaner ways to grow. Its royal founder brings with him the history of how Britain got rich.

There is a steel pole down the middle of the photograph. On one side sit Prince William and Catherine, Princess of Wales. Across the aisle, a woman in a green lanyard is speaking. The man who will be king is leaning forward to listen. Of the photos Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis shared from Monday’s ride on Mumbai Metro’s Aqua Line, this is the one I keep looking at.
Earlier that day, William and Catherine played gully cricket with Sachin Tendulkar and schoolgirls in Ballard Estate, a business district built beside the docks of colonial Bombay. By the time William got on the Metro, he was in a dark suit and tie. Ordinary clothes for a man whose wardrobe can, on the right occasion, include a sash and a sword.
The opposite of costly signaling
Plenty of people with vast fortunes pay to get across a city behind tinted glass. William can sit on a steel bench and have the picture travel around the world. His title does the work that a display of wealth would have to do for someone else.
Fadnavis welcomed the couple for experiencing Mumbai “like a Mumbaikar”. The Palace got a picture of an approachable prince. Mumbai got to show what it had built for its own people. I’ve lived in Mumbai and London, so I was curious about the comparisons with the Tube. William and Catherine rode London’s Elizabeth line to a Soho pub before the 2023 coronation, to meet people preparing for the celebrations. Here, on the ride from Vidhan Bhavan to Bandra Kurla Complex, the public transport itself was part of what they had come to see.
Why Earthshot came to India
This is the first time the Earthshot Prize has come to India, a country that has produced more Earthshot winners and finalists than any other. One of this year’s finalists, Mahindra Last Mile Mobility, used the Mumbai summit to announce a partnership with Uber to get more electric auto-rickshaws on the road. For a driver weighing up the cost of buying and charging one, the promise of cleaner transport has to work on a household budget. That is what balancing sustainability with progress looks like at street level.
Britain has reasons of its own to put the relationship on camera. Its free-trade agreement with India took effect in July, and the two countries have put clean energy and climate finance on the agenda of their Vision 2035 partnership. William and Catherine are due to meet Narendra Modi in Delhi. Britain wants a stake in the industries India is building. India gets to ask whose capital it wants, on what terms, and where the jobs and profits will go.
I keep thinking about the role of monarchy in the fifth industrial revolution. Here is a Crown championing a model in which a country can build industry, raise living standards and do less damage in the process. The same institution benefited from a much more coercive model. Britain enriched itself by impoverishing India. Raw cotton left India and machine-made British cloth came back. Indian weavers lost markets and incomes in an imperial economy that favoured manufacturers in Britain.
Is it penance or is it hypocrisy?
Is it just good PR? Karan Johar is hosting the awards, and the attention he and the royals bring can help teams raise serious money. Earthshot puts £1 million behind each of five winners and brings finalists together with potential investors. For a team with a working idea and the money to try it in only one neighbourhood, that is a good reason to welcome the prize.
Will Prince William apologise for the brutality of colonialism?
In 1997 his grandmother, Queen Elizabeth II, visited Jallianwala Bagh in Amritsar, where troops under British command opened fire on an unarmed crowd in 1919. Theresa May expressed deep regret in Parliament in 2019. This April, the Sikh Federation (UK) was still asking for a formal apology.
When William becomes king, he will be the United Kingdom’s head of state and Supreme Governor of the Church of England. An apology on Britain’s behalf would need the support of its elected government. I would like to know whether its future sovereign thinks Britain should give one, and whether he would be willing to say the words himself. Other countries that lived under British rule would be listening for what that meant for them.
Should India forgive? Of course the answer is yes. In the Catholic tradition I grew up with, penance means naming what you did and doing what you can to make amends. I would start with a plain apology for Jallianwala Bagh. I would look for Britain to make colonial records easier for Indian historians and affected families to access, and for its institutions to engage seriously with claims over objects taken under imperial rule. The families who still carry the memory of that day get to decide what forgiveness means to them, in their own time.
Is it a reconciliation or a reckoning? I want both. One day, I’d like to see William stand at Jallianwala Bagh and tell the families there, in plain words, what Britain did and what Britain is sorry for.





Comments