Nick Pasqual’s Conviction in Allie Shehorn Stabbing Explained

Nick Pasqual, who appeared in How I Met Your Mother, was convicted of attempted murder and five other felony counts on May 8, 2026, for the brutal stabbing of his ex-girlfriend. While the verdict provides a legal conclusion, the details of the 2024 attack and the actor's subsequent flight to the border reveal a chilling timeline of domestic violence that the legal system failed to prevent.  

Nick Pasqual Conviction Explained

On May 8, 2026, a Los Angeles jury found 36-year-old Nick Pasqual guilty on all counts, including attempted murder, first-degree residential burglary, and injuring a spouse/cohabitant. The conviction stems from a May 23, 2024, incident where Pasqual broke into the Sunland home of Hollywood makeup artist Allie Shehorn and stabbed her more than 20 times.  

Full Case Breakdown: The Attack and the Flight

The trial, which began in late April 2026, laid out a harrowing chronological sequence of events that began days before the actual attempted murder.

The Failed Safety Net

Evidence presented in court confirmed that Allie Shehorn had taken proactive steps to protect herself. She had obtained a restraining order against Pasqual shortly before the attack. Furthermore, Pasqual had been arrested for domestic violence on May 18, 2024—just five days before the stabbing—but was released after posting a $50,000 bond. Friends of Shehorn testified that Pasqual targeted her almost immediately upon his release.  

The Night of May 23, 2024

At approximately 4:30 a.m., Pasqual broke into Shehorn’s residence. During her emotional testimony, Shehorn described locking herself in a room as Pasqual "punched holes" through the door to reach her. She was eventually cornered and stabbed over 20 times, sustaining critical injuries to her neck, throat, chest, and back.  

Shehorn was discovered by a friend, Christine White, who found her lying in a pool of blood. White’s quick thinking—instructing Shehorn to keep pressure on her throat—is credited with saving her life before she underwent 14 hours of emergency reconstructive surgery.  

The Border Capture

Following the assault, Pasqual fled Southern California. He was eventually apprehended by U.S. Border Patrol agents at a checkpoint in Sierra Blanca, Texas, nearly two weeks after the crime, as he allegedly attempted to cross into Mexico.  

Sentencing and What’s Next

With the guilty verdict secured on May 8, the legal focus now shifts to the penalty phase.  

• Sentencing Date: Scheduled for June 2, 2026, at the San Fernando Courthouse.  

  
  

• Maximum Penalty: Pasqual faces a maximum sentence of life in prison.  

  
  

• Charges: The conviction includes special allegations of using a deadly weapon and inflicting great bodily injury, which will likely ensure a lengthy term without the possibility of early parole.

Quick Facts

Category	Detail
Defendant	Nick Pasqual (Actor, How I Met Your Mother)
Victim	Allie Shehorn (Makeup Artist, Babylon, Mean Girls)
Primary Conviction	Attempted Murder
Verdict Date	May 8, 2026
Sentencing Date	June 2, 2026
Status	Convicted; Awaiting Sentencing in Los Angeles

Frequently Asked Questions

Who did Nick Pasqual play in How I Met Your Mother?

Pasqual had a minor, uncredited role in the series. While often cited as a "HIMYM actor" in headlines, his professional career consisted mostly of small roles and background work in various television productions.

What is Allie Shehorn's current condition?

As of May 2026, Allie Shehorn has made significant strides in her recovery, though she appeared in court with visible scars on her neck and arms. She underwent extensive reconstructive surgeries and spent weeks in intensive care following the 2024 attack.  

Where was Nick Pasqual caught?

He was arrested in Sierra Blanca, Texas, at a U.S.-Mexico border checkpoint. He had fled California shortly after the stabbing incident occurred in Sunland.  

How many years will Nick Pasqual get?

While the formal sentencing is on June 2, 2026, the nature of the charges (attempted murder with special allegations) carries a potential life sentence under California law.