top of page

Kate and Rooney Mara Ate the Same Meals for Months to Play Werner Herzog's Inseparable Sisters

Writer: Khushi Taylor
Khushi Taylor
Sep 16
3 min read

A Herzog Fable Built on Sisterhood

Werner Herzog has never been shy about strange premises, and "Bucking Fastard" might be his strangest in years: a fable about sisters who speak in unison, dress identically and fall for the same man. For the roles, Herzog turned to real-life siblings Kate and Rooney Mara.

The film had already earned a standing ovation at its Venice premiere before arriving at TIFF, where it screened Monday, September 14, at the festival's midpoint — one of the fest's more unusual awards-adjacent titles this year.

It's a distinctly Herzogian left turn for the octogenarian director, who's spent a career moving fluidly between grand, obsessive epics like "Fitzcarraldo" and stranger, more intimate fables. Critics covering its Venice and Toronto premieres have described the film as sitting closer to the latter tradition — a small, odd story told with total conviction.

How the Mara Sisters Got In Sync

Playing characters that share nearly everything took some deliberate work off-camera. According to The Globe and Mail's reporting on the production, the sisters wore matching clothing to set each day and ate identical meals at the same time throughout the shoot, a small ritual meant to reinforce the characters' fused identities.

Rooney downplayed how much of a stretch that particular exercise was, noting she and Kate "would have been eating the same thing anyway" given how similar their tastes already run. Kate, for her part, described the process as a chance to lean into their real-life closeness: "It was really fun to be able to find all of the ways in which we're similar as people."

Quick Facts

  • Director: Werner Herzog

  • Leads: Kate Mara and Rooney Mara, playing sisters who speak in unison and share a love interest

  • Prep: Matching outfits on set and identical, simultaneously-timed meals throughout the shoot

  • Premieres: Venice Film Festival (standing ovation), then TIFF on September 14, 2026

  • Also in cast: Orlando Bloom, Domhnall Gleeson

From Venice Ovation to TIFF's Red Carpet

The TIFF screening drew a red-carpet turnout beyond the two leads — co-stars Orlando Bloom and Domhnall Gleeson also walked alongside the sisters, adding star power to a film that's otherwise built around a genuinely odd, intimate premise.

That combination — a festival-circuit ovation in Venice, a starry TIFF red carpet, and a premise built for conversation — has made "Bucking Fastard" one of the more discussed non-blockbuster titles of this year's Toronto lineup. Early trade reviews out of both festivals have zeroed in on the same thing: the Mara sisters' real chemistry as siblings translating, almost eerily, into the film's central conceit of two people who've never had to be anyone but each other.

A Small Cast, a Big Swing

Herzog's films rarely play it safe, and casting real sisters to play fictional ones who are borderline inseparable is very much in that tradition. The gimmick could easily have tipped into gimmickry, but early reactions out of both festivals suggest the Maras found genuine feeling underneath the premise's stranger edges.

Both actors have spent the past decade building substantial, largely separate careers — Rooney in prestige dramas like "Carol" and Kate across film and television — which made the decision to share a screen, let alone share a character's voice, a notable one for each of them individually as much as for the sisters as a pair.

With the film now making its way through the fall festival circuit, its next stop is a wider release — where audiences outside Venice and Toronto will get to judge for themselves whether Herzog's latest curiosity holds together outside a festival crowd's goodwill.

FAQs

Are Kate and Rooney Mara playing twins?

They play sisters written to speak in unison and share nearly everything, including a love interest — reports describe them as fused in behaviour rather than explicitly written as twins.

Did the film premiere before TIFF?

Yes — it debuted at the Venice Film Festival to a standing ovation before screening at TIFF on September 14, 2026.

Who else is in the cast?

Orlando Bloom and Domhnall Gleeson both appear in the film and attended its TIFF premiere.

How did the sisters prepare for such similar roles?

They wore matching clothes to set and ate identical meals together throughout filming, according to The Globe and Mail's reporting.

Comments


Advertisement

bottom of page