top of page

Imtiaz Ali's "Catalyst" Theory Has One Big Problem

Writer: Kenneth Hopkins
Kenneth Hopkins
Aug 17
5 min read

A reel doing the rounds this week claims to be "EXPOSING IMTIAZ ALI." It does nothing of the sort. What it actually does is hand the internet a genuinely useful piece of film criticism — and then bury it under a thumbnail built for outrage.



The creator, @life_itselffffff, lays out a clean thesis in the caption: Imtiaz Ali repeatedly writes a character type worth naming. Call it the Catalyst. Someone who does not change, but who brings about change in everyone around them. Set that against the montage of posters the reel runs — Rockstar, Highway, Tamasha, Love Aaj Kal, Jab We Met — and the pattern looks airtight.


It nearly is. But the single film the reel leads with is also the film that dismantles the theory, and nobody in the comments has clocked it.



The theory, stated properly

Strip away the thumbnail and the argument is a real one, with a real lineage. The Catalyst is a structural role, not a personality. The protagonist arrives broken, or asleep, or performing a version of themselves they don't believe in. The Catalyst walks in fully formed, refuses to bend, and the friction does the work. The protagonist is transformed. The Catalyst walks out roughly as they walked in.


Run the filmography and it holds up in places you'd expect it to.

Tamasha is the cleanest case. Tara meets Ved in Corsica, watches him perform a character, and then spends the rest of the film refusing to accept the smaller man he becomes in Delhi. She does not have an arc so much as a position — she knows who Ved is, and she will not pretend otherwise. Ved shatters and rebuilds. Tara holds.

Love Aaj Kal runs it even more explicitly. Veer Singh, played by Rishi Kapoor, is a man whose arc is already finished before the film begins. He exists to narrate, to contrast, to needle Jai into recognising what he's throwing away. He is a Catalyst by design — the film literally structures him as a completed story told to an incomplete one.

Rockstar has Heer detonate Janardhan and produce Jordan. Highway has Mahabir Bhati, a man with no interest whatsoever in personal growth, become the accidental engine of Veera's liberation.

So far, so good. The reel has found something.

Where it breaks

Then there's Geet.

Jab We Met is the poster the reel puts first, and on a surface read Geet Dhillon is the ultimate Catalyst — a whirlwind of noise and certainty who talks a suicidal Aditya Kashyap back into his own life and then hands him a company, a haircut and a personality. Change delivered. Catalyst confirmed.

Except the film does not stop there. It goes to Manali, and it finds Geet destroyed.

The second half of Jab We Met is a systematic undoing of exactly the character type the reel is celebrating. The girl who could not be interrupted goes quiet. The girl who was certain about everything cannot look her family in the eye. Anshuman happened, and the Catalyst broke. By the time Aditya finds her, the roles have inverted completely — the man she transformed is now the one doing the transforming, and he does it by playing her own tape back at her.

That is not a Catalyst. That is a character with the most complete arc in the film. And it is the single most-quoted, most-GIF'd, most-culturally-embedded thing Imtiaz Ali has ever written.

The reel opens with it and then argues the opposite.



The critique the reel is skirting

Here's the harder thing, and the reason "exposing" was probably the wrong word for a video that ends up being a compliment.

There is a genuine, long-standing criticism of this exact pattern in Imtiaz Ali's work, and the Catalyst framing walks right up to it without naming it. In the majority of these films, the Catalyst is a woman, the transformed party is a man, and the woman's interiority is the fuel rather than the subject. Tara exists in relation to Ved. Heer exists in relation to Jordan. The camera's curiosity, its patience, its long silences — those belong to the man.

Western criticism has a blunt name for this shape, and it isn't flattering.

What complicates the charge — and this is the part worth sitting with — is that Imtiaz Ali seems entirely aware of it. Highway inverts the gender assignment outright: Veera is the protagonist, Mahabir is the instrument, and the film's whole moral weight sits with her. Jab We Met breaks its own Catalyst on purpose. These aren't accidents in a filmography this consistent.

Which means the Catalyst isn't a blind spot. It's a device he keeps picking up, using, and then deliberately fracturing to see what falls out.

That's a more interesting claim than "exposing," and it's the one the reel had in hand the entire time.

One correction the carousel needs

The reel's poster montage includes Laila Majnu alongside the Imtiaz Ali films. It's an understandable slip and a common one, but it isn't accurate.

Laila Majnu (2018) was directed by Sajid Ali — Imtiaz's brother. Imtiaz co-wrote the screenplay with him, conceived the original idea, and presented the film. He did not direct it. The same applies in reverse for Amar Singh Chamkila (2024), which Imtiaz directed and Sajid co-wrote.

It matters here more than it usually would, because Qais is one of the strongest Catalyst arguments available — a man whose devotion is so unchanging it becomes a kind of madness — and the theory would be better served by claiming him accurately than by filing him under the wrong director.



The verdict

The framing is bait. The idea underneath it is sound and worth stealing.

If you want the Catalyst thesis in its strongest form, run it on Tamasha and Love Aaj Kal and leave Jab We Met out of it entirely. Geet isn't proof of the pattern. She's the film where Imtiaz Ali tested the pattern to destruction and decided the more interesting story was what happens when the person who changes everyone finally needs changing herself.

Twenty-something years into the filmography, that's still the scene everyone can quote.



Quick Facts

Imtiaz Ali directed Socha Na Tha (2005), Jab We Met (2007), Love Aaj Kal (2009), Rockstar (2011), Highway (2014), Tamasha (2015), Jab Harry Met Sejal (2017) and Amar Singh Chamkila (2024).

Laila Majnu (2018) was directed by Sajid Ali, with a screenplay co-written by Imtiaz Ali and Sajid Ali, and presented by Imtiaz Ali.

His catalogue is distributed across Netflix, Prime Video and JioHotstar depending on title and territory — availability differs between the India and US/UK/Canada/Australia libraries.


FAQs

What is the "Catalyst" character in Imtiaz Ali's films?

The Catalyst is a fan-coined term for a character who does not change themselves but causes profound change in the protagonist. Tara in Tamasha and Veer Singh in Love Aaj Kal are the clearest examples in his filmography.


Is Geet from Jab We Met a Catalyst character?

Not really — Geet has one of the most complete character arcs in the film. She transforms Aditya in the first half, then breaks down in the second half and needs him to pull her back, which inverts the Catalyst structure entirely.


Did Imtiaz Ali direct Laila Majnu?

No. Laila Majnu (2018) was directed by his brother Sajid Ali. Imtiaz Ali co-wrote the screenplay, conceived the idea and presented the film, but did not direct it.



Which Imtiaz Ali film best fits the Catalyst theory?

Tamasha (2015). Tara functions almost entirely as a fixed point against which Ved's identity crisis plays out — she refuses to accept the diminished version of him, and that refusal drives the entire second half.

Comments


Advertisement

bottom of page